The VASARI project utilizes a specialized algorithm for stitching together
the sub-images of its subject painting. This is made possible because the
system's exact registration allows for point to point matching. Again,
our registration was not perfect, so we resorted to commercial image mosaicing
software.
The QuickStitch software
We purchased QuickStitch 2.0, published by Enroute Imaging, a company based
in Palo Alto. This software loads up to 48 sub-images and stitches them
together into one large high-resolution image. Since it is consumer-oriented
software, there were only a few options to control the stitching algorithm.
These were the choices between perspective and panhead mapping, and between
gradual and sharp blending. Through correspondence with the engineering
manager of Enroute Imaging we learned more about these options:
Here are the images generated by all the permutations of the control options:"The Sharp/Gradual distinction dictates whether overlapping images are cross-blended or not. Cross-blending results in each image being partially visible in a semi-transparent way; when the images are not perfectly aligned, this results in a "ghosting" effect where slightly offset, semi-transparent duplicates of elements of the scene are visible. The Sharp setting turns off gradual blending, which makes the transition from one picture to another an abrupt one at some arbitrarily chosen seam. The benefit of Gradual is that it deals better with adjacent images that have different lighting characteristics. The benefit of Sharp is that it can minimize ghosting.The distinction between Perspective and Panhead is the distinction between seeing the composite image projected onto a flat wall vs. seeing it projected onto a cylinder that wraps around your point of view." -(from email correspondence)
Image stitched with Panhead algorithm and Gradual
blending
Image stitched with Panhead algorithm and Sharp blending
Image stitched with Perspective algorithm and Gradual
blending
Image stitched with Perspective algorithm and Sharp
blending
We chose the image rendered with the Panhead algorithm and Sharp blending as best.